[Complete Guide] What Kind of Cards Deserve a PSA 10 Rating?

Are you dreaming of your Pokémon cards coming back from PSA with that perfect Gem Mint 10 label? You’re not alone! A PSA 10 grade is the holy grail for collectors – it signifies a virtually perfect card. Such top-tier cards can command eye-popping prices (a 1st Edition Charizard PSA 10 sold for around $375,000 versus ~$20,000 in PSA 9) But a PSA 10 isn’t just about value; it’s proof your card is in pristine condition, with no visible flaws. So, what exactly does PSA look for when deciding if a Pokémon card deserves a 10? In this guide, we’ll break down the four key criteria – Centering, Corners, Edges, and Surface – and give you tips to pre-evaluate your cards at home. (Tip: Grab one of your cards now and follow along to see how it measures up!)

Example: This Charizard card is graded PSA 10 Gem Mint. Notice the impeccable condition and PSA’s label certifying its top grade. Gem Mint cards like this are prized for being essentially flawless.

Centering: Perfect Alignment of the Artwork

What Is Centering? Centering refers to how evenly the card’s printed image is positioned within the borders. In a perfectly centered card, the borders (top, bottom, left, right) are equal or very close in thickness. PSA puts heavy emphasis on centering because it greatly affects eye appeal – a card that’s noticeably off-center will immediately look “off” to a grader.

PSA 10 Centering Standards: To achieve Gem Mint centering, the image must be very close to centered. PSA’s official standard for a 10 is that the centering on the front should be no worse than about 55/45 (one border is at most ~1.2× the thickness of its opposite). On the back, PSA is a bit more lenient, allowing up to 75/25 off-center since backs are less visible. In simple terms, a PSA 10 can have a slight border size difference, but it should not be obvious at first glance. If the card is noticeably shifted to one side (e.g. 60/40 or worse on the front), it likely won’t get a 10.

How to Check Centering: Look at your Pokémon card under good light and compare the left and right borders – do they look equal? Do the same for top and bottom. You can even measure the border widths with a ruler or use a centering tool app for precision. A quick rule of thumb: if you can barely tell any difference in border thickness, the centering is probably within the 55/45 range. Call to Action: Try it now – pick a card and examine its borders. If one side’s yellow border is much thicker than the other, that card’s centering might hold it back from a PSA 10. But if all sides look evenly balanced, congratulations – your card’s centering is on point!

Corners: Sharp and Unblemished

Why Corners Matter: The corners of a card are usually the first spots to show wear. Think about it – those tiny 90° points can easily get nicked, bent, or frayed from handling. For PSA, Gem Mint 10 corners must be impeccable. In fact, PSA graders will scrutinize all four corners under magnification to ensure they are perfectly sharp. Any rounding, whitening (where the card stock shows through), or dings on a corner will drop the grade significantly.

PSA 10 Corner Standards: All four corners should be razor-sharp, as if the card just came out of a pack. There should be no visible fuzziness or softness to the points Under 10x magnification, PSA 10 corners still look clean and flawless. Even a tiny speck of white edging on a corner is enough to likely make it a PSA 9 instead of 10. In other words, zero whitening or wear is the goal.

How to Check Corners: Hold your card by the edges (to avoid adding fingerprints) and examine each corner closely. Use bright light and even a magnifying glass or your phone’s camera zoom. Ask yourself: Are the corner tips crisp 90° angles, or do they look a bit rounded? Is there any white dot or chipping on the very tip? On Pokémon cards (which have colored backs), look for white spots at the corner tips – those are signs of wear. Call to Action: Inspect your card’s corners now. A Gem Mint candidate will have all four corners looking factory-fresh. If you spot even a small ding or a white fleck, be aware that PSA will likely catch it too, which means a lower grade.

Edges: Clean, Smooth Borders with No Chipping

What PSA Looks For: Edges are the outer borders of the card, and like corners, they should be clean and unmarred for a PSA 10. This means no chipping of the card’s color, no whitening along the edges, and no nicks or dents. For Pokémon cards, edge wear often shows as tiny white specks along the blue back border. In a PSA 10, you shouldn’t see any of those – the edges will appear crisp and evenly colored.

PSA 10 Edge Standards: A Gem Mint card’s edges will have no visible wear or chipping under normal viewing. The border should look just as solid and sharp as when the card was printed. Minor edge flaws (like one little fleck of white) might be tolerated only if everything else is perfect, but generally any whitening can knock the grade down to a 9 or lower. PSA’s philosophy: pristine edges + sharp corners = a card that still looks pack-fresh.

How to Check Edges: Inspect the card’s perimeter. Tilt it in the light and look at both front and back sides of the edges. Pay special attention to the back, where most Pokémon cards have a dark blue border – even the smallest white dot will stand out against that dark color. Run a clean fingertip gently along the edge; it should feel smooth, with no rough spots. Try this: Examine the top edge of your card – do you see any white spots or chips? If yes, that’s edge wear. For a realistic shot at a 10, the edges should be flawless with solid coloring (no bits of cardboard core showing).

Surface: Flawless Front and Back Finish

The Importance of Surface: The surface encompasses the entire front and back face of the card. This is where scratches, print defects, and other blemishes can hide. PSA will closely inspect both sides under strong light, because even a gorgeous card with perfect centering and edges can fail to get a 10 if it has a surface flaw. A PSA 10 surface must be virtually perfect – meaning no scratches, no stains, no dents or creases, and a strong original gloss.

Common Surface Flaws (to Avoid): Pokémon cards, especially holographic ones, are notorious for certain issues: print lines (faint factory lines across the holo), scratches on the foil or glossy finish, pressure dents (like those caused by binder rings or pack sealing machines), and silvering or whitening on edges of holo areas. Even tiny holographic scratches or print lines can be the difference between a PSA 9 and PSA 10. PSA expects no visible imperfections at all on a Gem Mint card’s surface. The card should also have its original shine – PSA notes that full original gloss is a feature of a Gem Mint 10. There should be no staining or discoloration on the card; any stain will disqualify a card from a 10 (and likely from high grades in general). The only minor thing PSA might forgive is a tiny printing speck or dot if it’s very slight and doesn’t detract from the card’s overall look.

How to Check Surface: First, make sure your hands are clean or wear soft gloves – you don’t want to add fingerprints or smudges. Hold the card under a bright light (sunlight or a strong lamp) and tilt it slowly to catch any scratches or indentations. Do this for the front and the back. For holofoil cards, examine the holographic area at multiple angles to spot any print lines or scuffs. Use a flashlight at a low angle across the surface – sometimes this reveals dents or tiny bumps you might miss otherwise. Also, check for any marks or spots: things like ink dots, binder dents, or light stains. The card’s surface should look glossy and clean, like a mirror with no distractions. Give it a try: Take one of your shiny Pokémon cards and tilt it under a lamp. Can you see any fine lines or scratches in the foil? Are there any dull patches or fingerprints? A PSA 10-worthy card will have no visible surface flaws under normal viewing – it looks like it just came off the printing press.

Tips to Pre-Evaluate Your Cards (Before Sending to PSA)

Not every card will be a Gem Mint 10, but by pre-evaluating your cards, you can save time and grading fees by only sending your best candidates. Here’s a handy checklist to use before you submit:

• Centering Check: Measure or eyeball the borders. For PSA 10, you want roughly 55/45 or better centering on the front. If a card is clearly off-center, it’s likely not worth grading as a potential 10.

• Corner & Edge Inspection: Use good lighting and maybe a magnifier to examine all four corners and the card’s edges. Any whitening, ding, or fraying means the card is not perfect. Remember, even a tiny white nick on a corner can turn a 10 into a 9.

• Surface Scrutiny: Take your time to look over the card’s surface on both sides. Tilt it in the light to catch scratches or print lines. Check for dents by viewing the card at low angles. The surface should be glossy and clean with no scratches, stains, or indentations.

• Clean and Handle Carefully: Before packing your card for submission, gently remove any specks of dust with a soft, clean cloth or air blower. Do NOT try to wipe scratches (you can’t fix those) – only remove loose debris. Always hold the card by the edges to avoid adding fingerprints or flexing it. Place it in a penny sleeve and semi-rigid card holder for protection as you send it in.

Ready for Action? You now know exactly what qualities make a Pokémon card PSA 10 material. Take a few of your best cards and put them to the test using the criteria above. Practice grading them yourself – is the centering equal, are the corners flawless, are the edges smooth, and is the surface spotless? By honing your eye with these tips, you’ll get better at spotting true Gem Mint candidates. And when you do send your cards to PSA, you can do so with confidence. Good luck, and may your next package back from PSA be filled with Gem Mint 10 labels!

Sources: Professional Sports Authenticator (PSA) grading standards and expert guides – all confirming the strict requirements for centering, corners, edges, and surface that a card must meet to earn a PSA 10 grade. By understanding these benchmarks and examining your cards closely, you’ll be well on your way to recognizing what kind of cards truly deserve a PSA 10 rating. Enjoy the journey of grading, and happy collecting!

Explore Ravaver's Premium Card Binders Today!